Our Finger-Licking
Menu

BBQ Done Different

Whether you crave our mouthwatering wings or want to indulge in one of our famous pulled pork sandwiches, we’re sure we have something to satisfy your taste buds with the best BBQ on Long Island here at Smoke Shack. Discover the finest smoked meats made with the freshest ingredients and experience the masterpieces that made us famous whenever you visit our Mastic Beach location. And what better way to end the night than with one of our made-from-scratch milkshakes?!

Check out our dinner menu to discover all of your BBQ favorites and more. Don’t forget to ask about our daily specials!

Today’s Specials

Fan Favorites

The Mother Load | $13.99

Slow smoked pulled pork topped with thin sliced marinated flank steak & an egg cooked medium.

The Loaded Knish | $9.49

Potato knish topped with slow smoked pulled pork, signature BBQ sauce, nacho cheese, sour cream & scallions.

Pulled Pork Tacos (3) | $11.99
Homestyle coleslaw topped with slow smoked pulled pork.
Spicy Chicken Sandwich | $11.49
Grilled chicken tossed in hot as hell sauce topped with bacon, mozzarella cheese, lettuce & blue cheese.
Pulled Pork Sandwich | $13.99

Slow smoked pulled pork topped with homestyle coleslaw.

Smoked Brisket Sandwich | $13.49
Slow smoked, thin sliced brisket topped with signature BBQ sauce & homestyle coleslaw.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich | $10.99

Grilled chicken topped with bacon, mozzarella cheese, lettuce & mayo.

Shack Bites | $11.99

Boneless chicken bites tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with fresh hand-cut fries.

Teriyaki / Petey’s BBQ / Garlic Parmesan / Brook’s BBQ / Sweet & Sour / Buffalo / Golden BBQ / Sweet Chili / Hot As Hell / Tiger’s Blood / Go Cry To Ya Mama
Porky Mountain Fries | $12.99

Fresh hand-cut fries topped with slow smoked pulled pork, signature BBQ sauce, nacho cheese, sour cream & scallions

Nacho Explosion | $12.99

Nacho chips topped with a mountain of slow-smoked pulled pork, nacho cheese, sour cream, salsa, jalapeno peppers & scallions.

Burgers

All sandwiches and burgers are served with a choice of french fries or chips and macaroni salad. Upgrade to an order of small fries and a 12oz. drink for an additional $3.99
Cheeseburger* | $10.99

Hand pressed fresh burger* topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions & signature Petey’s sauce.

Bacon Cheeseburger* | $12.99

Hand pressed fresh burger* topped with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions & signature Petey’s sauce.

BBQ Bacon Burger* | $14.99

Hand pressed fresh burger* topped with mozzarella cheese, bacon & signature BBQ sauce.

Brunch Burger* | $15.99

Hand pressed fresh burger* topped with slow smoked pulled pork, bacon & an egg cooked medium.

Moon Burger* | $13.99

Hand pressed fresh burger* topped with Swiss cheese, sauteed onions & mushrooms.

Rodeo Burger* | $15.99
Mozzarella cheese, bacon, BBQ sauce & an onion ring.

Wraps

All wraps are served with a choice of french fries or potato chips and macaroni salad. Upgrade to an order of small fries and a 12oz. drink for an additional $3.99

Pulled Pork Wrap | $10.99
Slow-smoked pulled pork, bacon, lettuce tomato & homestyle coleslaw.
Chicken Wrap | $11.99
Grilled chicken, bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing.
Steak Wrap* | $12.99
Thin marinated flank steak*, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & Thousand Island dressing.
Brisket Wrap | $12.49
Slow-smoked pulled pork, lettuce, tomato & homestyle coleslaw.

Paninis

Amazing Chicken | $8.99
Breaded Chicken, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese & Onions.
Custom Cuban | $8.99
Smoked Pork, Swiss Cheese & Spicy Mustard.
Grilled Pastrami | $8.99
Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut & Spicy Mustard or Thousand Island Dressing.
C.B.R | $8.99
Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Swiss Cheese & Ranch Dressing.
NY Steak | $8.99
Flank Steak, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions & Zesty Horseradish Sauce on a Garlic Panini.

Quesadillas

Pulled Pork Quesadilla | $10.99
Served with sour cream & salsa.
Steak Quesadilla | $11.99
Served with sour cream & salsa.
Chicken Quesadilla | $9.99
Served with sour cream & salsa.
Brisket Quesadilla | $11.49
Served with sour cream & salsa.

Hot Dogs

Porky Mountain Hot Dog | $7.99

Sabrett hot dog topped with slow smoked pulled pork, signature BBQ sauce, nacho cheese, sour cream & scallions. Served on a hot dog bun.

Sabrett Hotdog | $2.99(1) • $4.99 (2)

Sabrett hot dog served on a fresh hot dog bun.
Add your choice of sauerkraut or onions.

Taco Trios

Includes 3 tacos.

BBQ Chicken | $10.99 (3)
Chicken topped with signature BBQ sauce, 3-cheese blend, tomatoes & scallions.
Pulled Pork | $11.99 (3)
Homestyle coleslaw topped with slow smoked pulled pork.
Brisket | $12.99 (3)

Slow smoked brisket topped with onions, 3-cheese blend & signature BBQ sauce.

Flank Steak* | $13.99 (3)
Marinated flank steak topped with 3-cheese blend, lettuce & tomatoes.

Chicken Lovers

Wings | $6.99 (4) • $8.99 (6)
$12.99 (10) • $23.99 (20)

Bone-in chicken wings tossed in your choice of sauce.

Teriyaki / Petey’s BBQ / Garlic Parmesan / Brook’s BBQ / Sweet & Sour / Buffalo / Golden BBQ / Sweet Chili / Hot As Hell / Tiger’s Blood / Go Cry To Ya Mama
Shack Bites | $11.99
Boneless chicken bites tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with fresh hand-cut fries.
Teriyaki / Petey’s BBQ / Garlic Parmesan / Brook’s BBQ / Sweet & Sour / Buffalo / Golden BBQ / Sweet Chili / Hot As Hell / Tiger’s Blood / Go Cry To Ya Mama

Nachos

Nacho Explosion | $13.99
Nacho chips topped with a mountain of slow-smoked pulled pork, nacho cheese, sour cream, salsa, jalapeno peppers & scallions.

Smoked Ribs

Smoked BBQ Ribs | $7.99 (3)
$12.99 (6) • $16.99 (9)
$20.99 (Whole Rack)
Slow smoked pork ribs smothered in signature BBQ sauce. Served with fresh hand-cut fries.

BYO Platters

Served With Cornbread

1 Meat Platter | $14.99+
2 Sides & 1 Beverage
2 Meats Platter | $19.99+
2 Sides & 1 Beverage
Meat Choices

Pulled Pork
3 Ribs Brisket
1/4 BBQ Chicken

Sides Choices
Baked Beans
Chips
Coleslaw
Corn on the Cob
Fires
Macaroni Salad
Beverage Choices
Coke – Diet Coke
Sprite – Dr.Pepper
Ginger Ale- Water
Arizona + $1.30
Hank’s + $1.30

Sides

Fresh Hand-Cut Fries | $4.99
Fresh Hand-Cut
Cheese Fries
 | $5.99
Fresh Hand-Cut
BBQ Cheese Fries
| $6.49
Macaroni Salad | $1.99 (1/4lb) /
$3.98 (1/2lb) / $7.69 (1lb)
Coleslaw | $1.99 (1/4lb) /
$3.98 (1/2lb) / $7.69 (1lb)
Beans | $1.99
Chips | $0.99
Corn Bread | $1.49
Texas Toast | $2.99
Mac N Cheese Wedges | $4.99
Onion Rings | $5.99
Mozzarella Sticks (5) | $6.99

Beverages

Water | $1.99
Canned Soda | $1.99
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Dr. Pepper
Ginger Ale
Arizona | $3.29

Iced Tea
Lemonade
1/2 Iced Tea & 1/2 Lemonade

Hank’s Soda | $3.29
Orange Cream
Root Beer
Black Cherry
Vanilla Cream
Monster | $3.99

Dessert

Ice Cream Cups:
Small | $4.99
Large | $6.99
Your choice of 1 flavor of homemade ice cream, 1 flavor of syrup & 1 type of sprinkles, topped with whipped cream & a cherry.
Milkshakes | $6.99

Your choice of 1 flavor of homemade ice cream blended with milk & topped with whipped cream.

Chocolate – Strawberry – Black & White
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – Vanilla
Chocolate Jelly Ring – Cherry Vanilla
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Cookies & Cream – Mint Chocolate Chip
Apple Eggroll | $7.99
Warm apple pie filling in an eggroll shell tossed in cinnamon sugar, paired with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with whipped cream.
Funnel Cake | $4.99
Funnel Cake Deluxe | $8.99
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich | $5.99
Fudge Brownie Deluxe | $5.99
Rainbow Cookie Cake | $4.99
Chocolate Chip Cookies (3) | $3.49
Rainbow Cookies | $3.99
Homemade Fudge Brownie | $2.49
Churro | $2.49

Smoke Shack delivers delicious BBQ straight to your door.

Save on delivery fees; Smoke Shack will come straight to your door with a simple phone call! We deliver within a 6-mile radius of our location.

CHECK OUT OUR DELICIOUS BITES

Have A Question
or Concern?


Contact Us For Questions About Our BBQ Menu Options

Whether you are looking for more information about our menu options and daily specials or would like to speak with someone directly — contact us today and see why people keep coming back for more!